Tuesday, April 21, 2009

Goldilocks And The Three Work-Life Balance Schemes

You'd think after all these years in academic research, I would've found the optimal balance between being more productive by taking work home with me, and protecting my personal life by leaving work behind in lab. But no, instead of occupying a happy middle ground, I swing wildly back-and-forth between doing absolutely no work at home and spending all my evenings and weekends working from home.

This bed is too hard.
During grad school, I didn't set any work-life boundaries at all. My labmates were also my buddies, and since they were similarly boundary-less, long days and nights in lab counted as both work and socializing. Work completely bled into life, but this was a perfectly adequate arrangement...until I encountered some roadblocks in my project. Since there was no time when I was completely free of work, when work wasn't going smoothly, well, I became miserable all the time. I had no protected work-free time in which to recharge, and I burned myself out.

This bed is too soft.
By the time I started my postdoc, I'd learned my lesson. I worked hard when I was in lab and stayed there till I had finished everything I needed to do. Once I left lab at the end of the day, I didn't let work intrude on my personal time. But there were problems with this arrangement as well. To get everything done without having to take work home, I had to be super-efficient during the day, leaving little time for interacting with my labmates. And since people tended to chat about their projects informally throughout the day, I missed out not only on the socializing but also on these impromptu scientific discussions. And then there were the late nights spent working on my computer in lab, wishing I were at least working on my computer at home with March Hare and Dormouse for company.

Where the hell is the bed that's just right?
In my current position, I do a lot less bench work and a lot more paperwork, which makes it all the more tempting to leave lab early enough to have dinner with March Hare everyday, and then work from home in the evenings. But March Hare tends to get a little annoyed (and rightfully so) when I ignore him all evening, or when he tries to have a conversation with me and I only actually hear 30% of what he's said. On the other hand, not bringing work home would either result in really long hours in lab or not getting nearly enough stuff done. Until I find the elusive "just right" solution, I've resorted to alternating between "too hard" and "too soft," depending on my workload, deadlines, and my mood. Not the most stable of solutions, but I still have a job and a husband, so it must be working, right?

15 comments:

alicia said...

"when I ignore him all evening, or when he tries to have a conversation with me and I only actually hear 30% of what he's said."
this is very true. :D
i have been trying to balance my life and work. my husband always told me: live for a life, not for work. :)

Prof-like Substance said...

I tend to do the same where I alternate my approach depending on the workload at the time. In the short term it doesn't feel like there is stability, but I think in the long term it evens out a bit. I probably spend more time at home not doing work this way, even if I spend the occassional week heading back to the lab after dinner and putting the Wee One down for the night.

Thomas Joseph said...

It's tough to get a perfect balance, and I'm not entirely sure it is possible. I've tried but I've finally hit on a compromise. When my wife has school work at night, I work from home. When my wife is out late, I stay late at work. I always try to keep Sundays open for down time, and at least one night a week for a "date night".

Otherwise, time can be spent working or relaxing, depending on the current deadlines. Like Prof-like Substance said ... it all sort of evens out in the long run. (One hopes anyways).

Amanda@Lady Scientist said...

this was a perfectly adequate arrangement...until I encountered some roadblocks in my project. Since there was no time when I was completely free of work, when work wasn't going smoothly, well, I became miserable all the time. Definitely me right now. I'm not quite sure how to swing away from this side of things, though. At least taking work home isn't an option :-D

ScienceGirl said...

The swinging pendulum is totally me, except we've got two of those in the household, which brings new complications when the pendulums are synced (Who's gonna do the laundry when we are both crazy busy at work?) or going in opposite directions (Would you like to go on a walk? - Don't you see I'm too busy?). I am hoping we find a way to get those pendulums to calm down a bit some time in the future...

Fia said...

I can see myself very clearly in the two states: The bed is too hard: grad-school pre-childbirth
the bed is too soft: grad-school post-childbirth

I miss the social interactions and think I'd do better if I'd join in more often, - but I know if I do, my work will suffer. Or my emotional stability.

Massimo (fka Okham) said...

If you ever figure this one out, please share it with me...

microbiologist xx said...

Yes, please share if you find a solution. I'll be your best friend forever...:)
I tend to swing back and forth as well. Like ThomasJoseph, I try to coordinate my schedule with my significant other, so that my work time isn't always cutting into "our" time, but I like my alone time with no work as well. sigh. I can't even imagine factoring a child into this equation.

bella said...

Aaah, I am so in the first bed.

"Since there was no time when I was completely free of work, when work wasn't going smoothly, well, I became miserable all the time. I had no protected work-free time in which to recharge, and I burned myself out."<===== my life in a nutshell right now

Mad Hatter said...

Alicia--I think your husband's right, but I seem to have a hard time actually implementing that!

PLS--I used to go back to lab at night when I lived close to campus, but now that it takes me 30 minutes each way, it just doesn't seem worth the trip unless whatever I have to do is really important.

Tom--We've tried coordinating schedules and it works pretty well when I'm just writing/reading. Doesn't work so well when I'm doing experiments since most of mine are planned weeks in advance.

Amanda--I don't know...unless your yeast are ts mutants, I'm guessing you could probably grow them in your oven if it's set to "warm"! :-) For what it's worth, even though our instinct may be to just work harder when faced with these roadblocks, sometimes a little distance may actually be more helpful. If you'd like to talk more about the grad school doldrums, feel free to email me (too.much.mercury@gmail.com).

ScienceGirl--We definitely have that problem too. We're actually pretty good at amusing ourselves when the other person has to work (blogging or Halo!). It's times when we're both crazy busy that's a problem.

Fia--Yeah, it's hard to balance bonding with labmates with work and family. We sometimes have "happy hours" in lab where we get together and have beer and junk food. Since it's in lab, it's usually pretty easy for everyone to take a short break from work and come hang out for a bit. Maybe your lab can try something like this?

Massimo--And here I was hoping you guys would provide the perfect solution in the comments!

MXX--I totally agree on the alone time. If I don't get enough time to myself (i.e., not working, not socializing, not dealing with people), I start getting cranky!

Bella--Sorry to hear you're feeling burned out. If it's any consolation, I think a lot of people go through this in grad school. Hope things get better for you soon.

chall said...

Mad Hatter> balance ? *mad laughter* I feel bad when I am not at work doing science or at home thinking about science. I have been trying to cut down on weekend work. Not because significant other and I necessarily do things but to be home at the same time and not sleeping.....

but please, when you find out how to do this; please please tell.

but I am better nowadays than when I was single. I worked all the time then. Now, i try and take more time off and hang out with friends too.... it's the alone time that suffers the most.

Mad Hatter said...

"I feel bad when I am not at work doing science or at home thinking about science."I know...I feel like I'm a bad scientist for not being totally obsessed with science all the time. Crazy, isn't it?

chall said...

MH. yes. it is crazy. the funny thing is that I think I make more good science thoughts sometimes when I am so far away from the bench and work... it's lie the abscence of actually being able to do anything about it gives my mind free range of thinking. If that makes sense? (or it is just my excuse for not being in lab all the time...)

Wayfarer Scientista said...

I love this analysis. Let us all know when if you figure it out!

Mad Hatter said...

Wayfarer--Thanks! And good to see you again!

Post a Comment