Sunday, June 22, 2008

Alternative Careers Blog

I noticed a long time ago that the top Google hits to this blog are on three posts I wrote on alternative career tracks in academia for PhD scientists*. I've also been contacted in real life by people at my institution who are interested in learning about my position and other non-traditional careers for PhDs. It seems that even though academia is becoming less hostile to alternative careers, there is still a dearth of open and honest discussion on a PhD scientist's options outside of the academic tenure-track.

Everyone I know who investigated alternative careers did so in secret out of fear of PI reprisals or of being labeled as a failure. As I discovered two years ago, this makes the process incredibly frustrating and lonely since one doesn't know where to go, or who to talk to, for information and help. In the end, I stumbled upon my current position only because someone offered it to me. All's well that ends well? Perhaps. But I would still prefer to not have spent months stumbling around in the dark by myself trying to find the right career path for me.

So I've been thinking about establishing a blog-based forum in which people can share their thoughts and information about alternative careers for PhD scientists. CAE and I have discussed this idea, and we think perhaps a multi-author blog along the lines of Active Academic and Economical Academic might be an appropriate format. Anyone who would like to discuss alternative science careers would be welcome to be a contributor on the alternative careers blog.

I'm envisioning a very broad definition of alternative careers--pretty much anything that isn't the dominant or traditional career path in your field counts--and an equally broad range of topics. I would love to have posts from people who have (or previously had) alternative careers discussing the pros and cons of those positions and offering advice or tips to those who might be interested in those positions. People who are still debating tenure-track vs. non-tenure-track, academia versus non-academia, or science versus non-science are also welcome to share their thoughts and experiences.

I think there are probably quite a few science bloggers who would have interesting experiences to share. CAE spent some time in industry but is now back in academia in a grant writing position. Bean-Mom, who took some time off to take care of her two lovely daughters, is now interviewing for a science writer position. Unbalanced Reaction recently graduated and will be moving on to a vising assistant professorship at a small liberal arts college. DrDrA has a great tenure-track position, but previously spent some time on the research track. Coturnix has a cool-sounding job of being the Online Community Manager at PLoS-ONE. EcoGeoFemme has been contemplating choosing non-professor positions after she graduates. And these are just a few people that I can think of off the top of my head!

So what do you all think? Is an alternative careers blog something you'd find interesting or helpful? Would you be interested in being a contributor or do you know someone who would?

*I'm excluding random hits from people searching for (1) tips on how to plan Alice in Wonderland themed parties, (2) "mad sex parties", and (3) info on cruise ship viral epidemics, which calls up one of my posts on noroviruses.

18 comments:

ScienceGirl said...

I'd certainly be an active reader of an Alternative Careers blog - and perhaps even a contributor in a few years :)

El said...

If you started a blog like that I might have to kiss you, or do something else equally embarassing out of joy. I would find something like that so absolutely useful, since I'm going to get a Ph.D. but I've been considering the idea that a TT job might not be for me and I have absolutely NO idea where to go from there.

EcoGeoFemme said...

That's a great idea! Do it!

Candid Engineer said...

I would love to read such a blog. I can't say I'd have anything to contribute, but I'd love to hear other people's experiences/ideas.

hypoglycemiagirl said...

Briliant idea!

JaneB said...

I'd be an interested reader - if only to learn about alternatives for my students/younger colleagues!

Yttrai said...

I too would read it voraciously, although i wimped out and am changing careers the boring standard way - going back to school. Of course, i only have an MS so perhaps that's why i wasn't able to make a more seamless transition?

Anyway, any advice or personal anecdotes related would be immensely helpful to the people trying to follow us.

CAE said...

I'm in as a contributor if you decide to go ahead! I think this is an excellent idea, as we've discussed before.

drdrA said...

Awesome idea. How about 'Alternative Academic'?

You know, Anonymoustache left some comments over at my blog about small biotech...

And I myself did both a non-tenure track job, and a short stint in industry as well.

I'm sure there is tons of material out there for such a blog...

ScientistMother said...

I think its an excellent idea! I worked as an Imaging and Microscopy Specialist before returning to do my PhD, I know tons of people who have chosen alternative careers and it was always a difficult decision because of the "failure" aspects.

Alice said...

My alternative faculty position was almost a career ending move and the anger and frustration at how women are pushed into these alternative positions drove me to start my blog. Regardless I think it is a great idea to start a blog on it. I can think of a number of warning signs I missed in hindsight and if they were out there then others would be able to negotiate a better situation for themselves and avoid my mistakes. Alternative faculty positions are highly individualistic and the more you have in writing before you start the better. God forbid you end up in a situation like I did where you have to do whatever the boss expects when you have no idea what he expects in advance.

The bean-mom said...

Awesome idea!!!

If I make the transition to an "alternative" career (and I think that I probably will), I'd love to contribute!

And regardless of what I do, I would love to read it. Ye gods, such a blog is what I've been seeking for ages...

Mad Hatter said...

Thanks, everyone! I'm really excited that there is this much interest! :-)

I'll start working on setting up the blog and will send email invites to everyone who would like to contribute. I'll post an announcement when I have it up and running, so check back here for updates.

Mad Hatter said...

ScienceGirl, EGF, Candid, HG--Thanks!

El--LOL! Kisses not necessary, but I appreciate the thought! :-) I think it's great that you're already thinking ahead about career choices. Thanks for visiting and commenting!

JaneB--Thanks for your comment! I found your blog through Propter Doc and have been lurking. I'll come over and say hello properly soon!

Yttrai--I think whether a seamless transition can be made probably depends mostly on what field you're in and what you're switching to. Good luck with the career change! I wasn't able to access your blogger profile from the link in your comment, so if you'd like to be a contributor on the alternative careers blog, please leave me your email address in the comments or send it to me at too.much.mercury AT gmail DOT com. Thanks for visiting!

CAE--Awesome! Thanks for all your suggestions on this!

DrDrA--Thanks for suggesting Anonymoustache. I'll have to go check out his(?) blog! I didn't know you were in industry too. I'd definitely be interested in hearing about that!

ScientistMother--Yeah, the "failure" thing is very difficult to get past, especially if one stays in academia. I think that'll make a great post topic sometime!

Alice--I think the overrepresentation of women in alternative positions, particularly in academia, is a really interesting topic. I would love to hear what you have to say on that.

Bean-Mom--Yeah, I wish there had been an alternative careers blog when I was deep in career angst several years ago. Perhaps I can start the blog, build a time machine, and go back and do it all over again, but this time armed with the right information? :-)

Drugmonkey said...

It is a bit narrow and may not count as "alternative" but I had the following observations on the old blog:

http://drugmonkey.wordpress.com/2007/07/06/routes-to-independence-beyond-ye-olde-skool-tenure-track-assistant-professorships/

http://drugmonkey.wordpress.com/2007/07/05/what-constitutes-a-real-job-in-biomedical-science/

Yttrai said...

Thanks for the positive feedback.

I am not a blogger. (Tangentially, i comment a lot on science-y blogs and they always assume i am a blogger too. That strikes me as odd, for reasons i haven't figured out yet.)

Anyway, my email is this username at gmail et cetera. Drop me a line, but not being a blogger i could only contribute in normal informal journal format.

Mad Hatter said...

DM--I think I've come across those posts before...through links on DrDrA's blog, I think. Thanks!

Yttrai--I think it's probably because you have a Blogger account--makes us jump to conclusions! :-) I was under the impression that one didn't have to have their own blog to contribute to a group blog. I might be wrong, but I'll send you an invitation to be a contributor when the site is up anyway, and if you want to, you can see if it'll work!

Rhea Miller said...

Some students at my University have head up a 'Alternatives in Science' club where they invite people from all kinds of jobs to talk about what they do and how to get your foot in the door...the meetings are always nice to attend...and i would certainly enjoy getting more information from all over the US. if you would like, i would love to share any interesting presentations i see!!

Post a Comment